Article

Culture Is a Risk Control: Your Values Only Count When They Cost You Something

November 20, 2026 | 7 minutes reading time | By David S. Cohen

Firms measure culture as an outcome. They should be designing it as a control, and testing it the way they test every other control: under pressure.

The strategy is clear. The growth targets are set. The opportunity in front of the leadership team is profitable, and on paper it fits. Then someone in the room says quietly that pursuing it would mean acting against what the organization says it stands for.

What happens next is the most important risk decision the firm will make that year, and it will never appear in a risk register.

If leaders hesitate and treat the moment as a dilemma, their people begin to wonder whether the values were ever real. If leaders act against the values, the good people start updating their résumés. Worse, those who were never aligned with the values take it as permission to pursue profit at any cost.

That is how conduct failures begin. Not with a single bad decision, but with a signal that the values are negotiable.

Culture Is Not Intangible

When I was teaching, the standard textbook on organisational development described culture as an intangible. That is false. Anyone whose values have been violated knows exactly where they feel it: in the gut.

The reason is simple. A value is a strongly held belief. It is emotionally charged, resistant to change and universally applied. People do not experience a breach of values as an abstraction. They experience it as a betrayal.

Regulators have come to the same conclusion from a different direction. In its November 2024 regulatory notice on culture risk management, Canada’s Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) describes culture as “the commonly held values, mindsets, beliefs, and assumptions that guide what is important.” It defines culture risk as “the misalignment between a financial institution’s stated desired culture and its actual culture.”

dcohen - 160 x 190David S. Cohen, Ed.D.

Read closely, that definition explains why values are what keep an organization on course. Strategy tells a firm where to go. Values tell it what it will and will not do to get there. When the two pull apart, the gap OSFI describes opens, and it widens every time leaders choose the target over the value.

The European Central Bank has moved the same way, asking banks to define their values and code of conduct and listing red flags such as a lack of challenge and debate within management. The direction is clear. Culture is no longer a soft topic for the HR function. It is a supervisory expectation.

Yet most firms still treat culture as something to measure after the fact, through engagement surveys and dashboards. That approach describes the culture. It does not control it.

Values Are the Control Design

Values are not a label that exists to satisfy a board requirement. They are expressed in the actions people take when they make a decision or react to a problem. They are the ethical code of conduct that defines right from wrong. They are the promise made to every new hire: This is how we will treat you, and this is how we will solve problems together.

In risk terms, value behaviors are the control design. They tell the organization whether an efficient way of operating is also ethically appropriate. Separate the two, and the system eventually does whatever it wants.

So here is the definition I work from. Culture is the set of value behaviors that define what is right in an organization, made visible in everyday decisions, together with a demonstrated willingness to give up a position or a financial benefit in order to live those values.

The second half of that definition is the part most frameworks leave out, and it is the part that makes culture a control. Consider three organizations that faced the test.

Wells Fargo put sales targets ahead of its stated values. Employees opened roughly 3.5 milion .unauthorised accounts between 2009 and 2016. The result was a $3 billion settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice, the departure of senior leaders, lasting reputational damage, and a Federal Reserve-imposed cap on assets from 2018 until June 2025.

Starbucks took the opposite path. In April 2018, two Black men were arrested in a Philadelphia store while waiting for a business meeting. Within weeks, the company closed more than 8,000 North American stores for an afternoon to train employees on its values, at an estimated cost of about $7 million in lost sales. It was a short-term loss that validated the values and energized employees.

Johnson & Johnson has kept its Credo, written in 1943, at the center of its decisions for more than 80 years. It held Credo Challenge meetings so leaders could test whether the values still held, and surveyed employees worldwide on how well the company was living up to them. The Credo puts responsibility to the people it serves ahead of return to shareholders, and in 1982 it guided the decision to pull Tylenol from shelves nationwide.

The decision was not free. J&J’s shares lost about 29% of their value, roughly $2.3 billion, and the recall cost another $100 million. James Burke, then chairman and chief executive, had no guarantee the market would forgive him. It did. The shares recovered within months, and within a year Tylenol had regained its market leadership.

Compare that with Wells Fargo, where seven years under a regulatory asset cap followed the choice of targets over values. The lesson is not only that living one’s values pays; but it is that the cost of living them is usually smaller, shorter and more recoverable than the cost of abandoning them.

One firm treated its values as negotiable. The other two treated them as non-negotiable and paid for the privilege. Only the second choice was a risk control.

How Culture Works As a Control

Risk professionals already think in terms of preventive, detective and corrective controls. Culture belongs in all three.

Preventive: selection. The first control point is the hiring decision. Most firms hire for credentials and experience, then hope the values follow. They rarely do. When value behaviors are defined clearly enough to interview against, selection becomes the first line of cultural defense. A hiring error is not just a talent problem. It is a risk event that compounds over time.

Detective: honest management. Drift shows up early in conversations that managers either have or avoid. Honest management is a safeguard. Avoidance is a vulnerability. A manager who addresses a small breach today prevents a pattern tomorrow. A manager who looks away is telling the team what the real standard is.

Corrective: acting on the high performer. Every organization has someone whose results are strong but whose behavior damages colleagues. Leaders tolerate that person because the numbers look good. But tolerated behavior becomes accepted behavior, and accepted behavior is where many conduct failures begin. Acting on that person, even at a cost to short term results, is the clearest signal a leadership team can send.

When these controls are absent, the outcome is predictable. TD Bank, one of Canada’s largest institutions, pleaded guilty in October 2024 to U.S. anti-money laundering failures and agreed to a $3.09 billion penalty along with a cap on U.S. growth. The Attorney General said the bank had created an environment “that allowed financial crime to flourish,” and by making its services convenient for criminals, “it became one.”

Boeing offers the same lesson. Two 737 MAX crashes in 2018 and 2019 killed 346 people, and a door panel blew out of an Alaska Airlines 737 MAX 9 in January 2024. Each event prompted renewed scrutiny of a culture in which production and cost pressures were seen to override safety and engineering judgment.

In each case, operational efficiency was pursued while values were set aside. The result was a short-term win and a far larger long-term loss.

Testing Operating Effectiveness

Risk professionals separate control design from operating effectiveness. A control that looks sound on paper but has never been tested is assumed to be weak until proven otherwise.

Values deserve the same discipline. A value that has never cost the organization anything is an untested control. Values are not aspirational ideals that appear when times are good. They are the ground rules for when times are hard, and living them in hard times is what defines the strength of an organization’s character.

Six questions will tell a chief risk officer or a board whether the culture control is actually operating:

1. When did we last walk away from revenue, a client or a deal because it conflicted with our values?

2. How many strong performers have we exited, or declined to promote, because of how they behave?

3. Are our values written as Hallmark greeting card platitudes, or as outcomes that leave people free to act however they wish? Or are they stated as clearly observable behaviors?

4. Are our values integrated into the hiring process as a foundational measure, so that every new hire is assessed for alignment before an offer is made?

5. Do our managers raise concerns early and honestly, or do issues surface only when they become incidents?

6. When employees are asked what the organization really rewards, does their answer match the values on the wall?

If the answers are vague, the control has not been tested. If the honest answer to the first question is “never,” then the firm is carrying a cultural exposure it has not yet measured.

The Control That Works When No One Is Watching

Policies, limits and monitoring all depend on someone checking. Culture is the control that operates when no one is checking: in the meeting where the profitable shortcut is proposed, in the interview where a strong candidate shows poor judgment, and in the quiet moment when a manager decides whether to address a star performer’s behavior.

Bob Dylan wrote that “to live outside the law, you must be honest.” Organizations live inside the law, but the principle holds. The rules will never cover every situation. Values cover the rest, but only if leaders are willing to pay for them.

OSFI is right that culture risk lives in the gap between the culture a firm claims and the culture it has. The way to close that gap is not another survey. It is a leadership team that defines its values as behaviors, hires against them, manages honestly to them, and proves them by being willing to lose something to keep them.

That is not an HR program. It is a risk control, and it may be the most important one a firm has.

 

 

David S. Cohen, Ed.D., is the founder and principal of DS Cohen & Associates, a Toronto-based organizational consulting firm specializing in corporate culture, employee experience, talent selection and leadership development. He is the author of “The Talent Edge”, “Inside the Box” and “Selecting the Best”, a LinkedIn Top Voice on culture, and ranked among the Global Gurus Top 30 for Organizational Culture. He can be reached at david@sagltd.com.

Topics: Conduct & Ethics, Enterprise, Career Development

In this article
Share

Related Insights